The
Boycott of the Centro is Still in Effect!
April 13, 2007
For Immediate Release
Contact: community@saveourcentro.org
CENTRO CULTURAL DE LA RAZA LEGACY EXHIBIT POSTPONED
In order to best resolve the Boycott of the Centro Cultural de La Raza in San Diego and acknowledge the gains made by the current Mediation process, the joint SOCC/Centro Transition Team, in conjunction with the Centro Board has decided to postpone the Centro's upcoming Legacy Initiative Exhibition until the resolution of the Boycott.
Since November of 2005, the National Conflict Resolution Center began to work with members of the Centro Board and the Save Our Centro Coalition (SOCC) to begin the process for ending the 7 year Boycott of the historic Chicano/a community cultural arts center.
To this end, a joint Transition Team, which is comprised of Save Our Centro Coalition and Centro Board members, was formed to lead the organization into a re-unification with its community.
The Transition Team members understand the importance of having artists involved in the exhibition of their work and having adequate curatorial support to make this possible.
Together the Centro and the Save Our Centro Coaliton will collaborate on a Legacy Initiative that will celebrate and reintegrate the vibrant Chicano/a arts community back into its historic home in San Diego's Balboa Park.
A public announcement detailing the date of this future exhibit -- and the expected end of the Boycott -- will be made at Chicano Park Day on April 21, 2007.
-- The SOCC/Centro Transition Team
April 12, 2007
San Diego Union Tribune
Monday, November 6, 2006
Centro Seeking New Director
LATINO ARTS: Centro Cultural de la Raza – the Balboa Park organization that has come under fire for supposedly not living up to its mission – is seeking a new executive director in the wake of the sudden resignation of Rick Hernandez.
Centro artistic director Viviana Acosta confirmed Hernandez left the organization Oct. 31. “He left for personal reasons,” said Acosta, who was unable to elaborate.
Hernandez, 36, could not be reached for comment. He was hired by the Centro board in October of last year. His arrival had been expected to quell the strife that has plagued the Centro for the past seven years. The 36-year-old institution has been criticized by some artists, Latino community leaders and others for “not being open and responsive” to the aspirations of the “Chicano/a, Mexicano/a indigenous community.” The Save Our Centro Coalition has led the attack, spearheading a boycott of the facility.
The Centro has posted the executive director job opening on its Web site and also on the jobs page of the San Diego Performing Arts League.
– Preston Turegano
Monday,
Dec. 26, 2005
Centro Makes Enlace's Worst of 2005 list
"Los
directivos del Centro Cultural de la Raza han sido incapaces,
poruna falta cronica de liderazgo, de resolver una disputa
con un grupo de artistas que desde el año 2000 han
realizado un boicot del lugar." - Enlace, Dec. 26
"The directors of the Centro Cultural
de la Raza have been incapable, due to a chronic lack of
leadership, of resolving a dispute with a group of artists
who, since the year 2000 have realized a boycott of the
space." - Enlace, Dec. 26
Click here to
read Enlace Story on Nov. 6 Letdown
Friday,
Nov. 11, 2005
La Prensa Blasts
Centro Board
"The
Centro Board has shamed the community! They ignored the reasons
of the founding of El Centro Cultural and the significance
the Centro represented to all La Raza and our City! They have
lost their soul.
The
Centro Board does not merit the support of the Hispanos, Mexican
Americans, and Chicanos or of any other community who uses
the Arts to bring history alive and place on display it's
historical significance."
November 7, 2005
PRESS RELEASE
For
Immediate Release November 7, 2005
Contact: Sandra Sarmiento
Phone: 619-234-3880
Armed
Guards Aggravate Community:
Boycott of Centro Cultural de la Raza Maintained
NALAC
Withdraws Participation, Chunky Sanchez Denounces Board
After
negotiating on Sunday for three hours outside the Centro Cultural
de la Raza with the help of mediators, a large crowd of community
members was frustrated in their attempt to hold an open community
meeting at the historic cultural center in Balboa Park. Facing
armed undercover security hired by the Centro, the crowd voted
to maintain the five-year boycott of the institution.
The
group outside, which included original Centro founders as well
as former Boardmembers and staff, claimed that the Centro Board's
hiring of armed, off duty San Diego Police officers violated
the integrity of the eleven-month negotiation process between
representatives of the Centro and the Save Our Centro Coalition
(SOCC).
SOCC
representatives received an email from Centro Board President
Aurelia Flores late Friday afternnoon, stating that the Centro
had hired armed off duty San Diego Police officers as security
for the Sunday meeting.
"(The
guards) will be armed, but will be in casual clothing and the
arms will be concealed," stated Flores in her email.
Maria
de Leon, Executive Director of the National Association of Latino
Arts and Culture (NALAC) refused to participate in the meeting
due to the hiring of armed guards. She cancelled her flight
late Saturday night after discussing the issue with the NALAC
Board.
"NALAC
will not participate in a meeting with an organization such
as Centro Cultural that treats another organization, artists
and the community in this manner. We are troubled by the actions
of the Centro Cultural and do not condone armed meetings with
our communities," said de Leon.
Local
musician Ramon "Chunky" Sanchez, whose work is featured
in the recent Smithsonian compilation "Rolas de Aztlan,"
denounced the BoardÕs actions via a statement.
The
Save Our Centro Coalition stated to Boardmember Juan Zuñiga
that it was against the Centro's Affirmation of Conduct Values
policy to bring weapons of any kind into the Centro. The group
asked that the Boardmembers who authorized this action be accountable
to the Centro's own regulations.
Among
the approximately 100 people who had come to the Centro seeking
answers to the 17 point Audit Petition were Centro founders,
former Boardmembers and staff such as UCSD professor Jorge Mariscal,
business leader Scott Kessler, former Centro curators Eloissa
Leonna and Patricio Chavez, muralists Victor Ochoa and Sal Barajas
and former Centro Ballet Folklorico en Aztlan director Teresa
Caballero. Members of the Chicano Park Steering Committee, families
with children and numerous local artists and community leaders
were also in attendance.
Others
who had hoped to participate in the historic gathering stayed
away due to the presence of armed undercover guards. The day
ended with the community voting to maintain the boycott of the
Centro Cultural de la Raza.
"The
boycott remains in full effect," said SOCC representative Victor
Payan.
For
more information, please email community@saveourcentro.org or call 619-234-3880.
Click
Here for More Photos
September 16, 2005
La Prensa de San Diego
The struggle continues...
The SOCC demonstrate outside the Centro Cultural de la Raza to demand a response
By Pablo Jaime Sainz
After three months of not doing any demonstrations as part of a truce, the Save Our Centro Coalition (SOCC) held a protest last Thursday September 8 outside the Centro Cultural de la Raza, in Balboa Park.
The reason? The Centro’s board hadn’t shown any sign of continuing the dialogue, according to Sandra Peña Sarmiento, SOCC’s member and organizer.
Click here for full story.
August
31, 2005
SOCC
AWAITS BOARD RESPONSE
The SOCC is currently awaiting response from the Cento Board as
to the date and location of the community meeting and the list of
desired outcomes presented at the June 7 planning session. The boycott
remains in effect pending a positive resolution of the discussions.
We
will keep the community posted via emails and updates to the website.
To contact the Save Our Centro Coalition, please email centrowatch@aol.com.
The
list of desired outcomes presented to the Board on June 7 include
but are not limited to:
Reinstatement
of the Arts Advisory Committees with voting Board seats
Community representation on Board
Legitimate
national search for all Centro staff positions
SOCC
participation in selection of Executive Director and staff
Abolish
Affirmation of Conduct Values and exclusionary policies
Accountability
to the community
Open
Board meetings
Publicly
posted minutes
June 7,
2005
SOCC
MEETS WITH CENTRO BOARD TO PLAN COMMUNITY MEETING
SOCC
members Carlos C. de Baca, David Rico, Sandra Sarmiento and Victor
Payan met with Centro Board President Aurelia Flores and Boardmembers
Juan Zuniga and Nadia Bermudez on Tuesday, June 7 to discuss the boycott
and plan for the upcoming community meeting. The meeting was productive,
and the Boardmembers received a lot of information to take back to
the Board. They have requested another planning session before the
community meeting.
The
boycott remains in effect pending a positive resolution of the discussions.
The
SOCC presented a packet of information, which included a list of desired
outcomes. These include but are not limited to:
Reinstatement
of the Arts Advisory Committees with voting Board seats
Community
representation on Board
Legitimate
national search for all Centro staff positions
SOCC
participation in selection of Executive Director and staff
Abolish
Affirmation of Conduct Values and exclusionary policies
Accountability
to the community
Open
Board meetings
Publicly
posted minutes
We
are hopeful that the Board will work with the SOCC to resolve the boycott
and re-establish the Centro as a safe, relevant and dynamic cultural
center that is accountable to the community and supports its empowerment
through art, culture and activism. In addition, we were told that Nancy
Rodriguez has stepped down as Executive Director, but has been kept
on as a consultant. She has also been asked to join the Board.
We
would like to thank all those who have respected the boycott and supported
the efforts of the SOCC to bring the Centro back to the community.
La
Lucha Continua,
Save
Our Centro Coalition
For
more information, please contact info@saveourcentro.org
June
3 , 2005
Lalo
Alcaraz Pulls His Artwork from Centro Exhibit
Nationally-syndicated
cartoonist Lalo Alcaraz has demandsed that his artwork "Run, Bush,
Run" be removed from a touring exhibit at the Centro Cultural de
la Raza in solidarity with the community boycott of the once-dynamic
community cultural arts center.
Alcaraz joins artists
Richard Lou and Robert Sanchez in removing their artwork from the exhibit
at the Centro, an organization that has been the subject of a five-year
boycott. The boycott began in May 2000 when the administration refused
to resolve the community's concerns about censorship, the destruction
of art, the elimination of a representative Arts Advisory Committee,
the forcing of a Chicana activist off the Board, nepotism and the hiring
of an Executive Director without a national search. The administration
used police to lock out the community and end dialogue.
For more information,
please contact the Save Our Centro Coalition at centrowatch@aol.com.
The email below
has been forwarded to the Centro Cultural de la Raza and Carolina Ponce
de Leon, Executive Director of the Galeria de la RAza, the parent institution
of the exhibit at the Centro.
Subj: SD EXHIBIT
Date: Friday, June 3, 2005 11:47:35 AM
From: pocho@pocho.com
To: Centrowatch@aol.com
To whom it may concern:
I was surprised to read that one of my artworks is on display at San
Diego's Centro Cultural de La Raza as part of a traveling show originating
at San Francisco's Galeria de la Raza. I am a participant in the boycott
against the Centro Cultural de la Raza and have vowed not to perform
or present artwork in that venue until significant issues regarding
the administration's stance against Chicano artists are resolved.
I request that my
artwork, "Run, Bush, Run," be removed immediately from the exhibit at
the Centro Cultural de la Raza and that this statement be displayed
in its place.
LALO ALCARAZ Nationally
Syndicated Comic Strip Artist, "La Cucaracha" --
********************************************************************************************************
http://www.lacucaracha.com
http://www.pocho.com http://www.cartoonista.com
listen to the POCHO
HOUR OF POWER, Fridays at 4pm PST on KPFK 90.7FM for live streaming
visit http://www.zkpfk.org
April 26, 2005
SOCC
Makes Presentation to Centro Board
Dear Save Our Centro
Members and Supporters,
After five years
of requesting dialogue not denial from the Centro, the Save Our Centro
Coalition made a presentation at the April 26 Centro Board meeting.
The Board consists of mainly new members, as there has been a high turnover
rate in recent years. Aida Mancillas was no longer listed as being on
the Board and was not present at the meeting. Executive Director Nancy
Rodriguez and ballet folklorico instructor Viviana Enrique were in attendance.
Save Our Centro
representatives Endy Bernal and Sandra Sarmiento gave a five-minute
presentation at the morning meeting, which was held at the Old Gallery
coffee shop in downtown San Diego. They handed Save Our Centro buttons
to all in attendance and read a prepared statement inviting the Board
to participate in a community forum mediated by representatives of the
National Association of Latino Arts and Culture.
The Board was asked
to provide a written response by May 10 indicating their participation
in this important first step at resolving the serious issues which resulted
in the ongoing boycott.
As we await the
Board's response, we ask all artists, organizations and individuals
to respect the boycott and continue to support the SOCC effort to return
the Centro to the community. We are hopeful that the new Board members
will not express the antagonism toward the community that characterized
their predecessors.
We thank you all
for your continued support and encourage you to contact us at centrowatch@aol.com
if you wish to participate in a community forum. For continued information
and updates, please visit our website, www.saveourcentro.org.
La Lucha Continua,
Save Our Centro Coalition
www.saveourcentro.org
SOCC April
26 Presentation to Centro Board
April 26, 2005
Dear Members of
the Board of the Centro Cultural de la Raza,
We thank you for
honoring the Save Our Centro Coalitionšs longstanding request for dialogue
to resolve the current situation. Five years is a long time to wait
for this opportunity, and we cannot underscore its importance. Since
many of you are new to the Board, we will provide a brief introduction.
We are here as representatives
of the Save Our Centro Coalition, a large group of artists, activists,
educators and community members committed to serving the needs of the
community. Our Coalition includes Centro founders, former Board members,
curators and the Centrošs Arts Advisory Committee. We are a nationally-respected
and award-winning group of leaders in poetry, publishing, music, dance,
drama, film, journalism, photography, painting and performance.
Our members work
throughout the community to produce such events as Chicano Park Day,
the Barrio Bookfest, the Adams Avenue Street Fair, the City Heights
International Village Celebration, San Diego Latino Film Festival and
the annual International Dia de la Mujer Celebration.
We have contributed
our expertise to organizations such as the Museum of Contemporary Art,
the Sherman Heights Community Center, the Childrenšs Museum, Bienestar,
Chicano Perk Café and afterschool programs throughout San Diego.
SOCC members have
served on the Boards of numerous organizations, including Voz Alta,
the City-County HIV Housing Committee, PACTO and the Media Arts Center
San Diego.
We are here today
to offer you a plan to bring our resources back to the Centro.
For thirty years,
the Centro Cultural de la Raza was the dynamic epicenter of Latino arts
and culture in San Diego. It was founded by the same community that
founded Chicano Park and shared a common vision of social justice and
community empowerment.
This vision attracted
and nurtured internationally recognized artists and groups such as Guillermo
Gomez Peņa, Judy Baca, Los Lobos, Culture Clash, the Border Arts Workshop,
Lourdes Portillo, Gronk, Lalo Lopez Alcaraz and many others.
Five years ago,
many mistakes were made that resulted in the alienation and exclusion
of the community from the Centro. We both know that differences still
exist and that sincere effort is necessary to resolve them. But these
differences must be resolved now for the good of all.
Fulfilling the Centrošs
original mission as a community space, a resolution can only be accomplished
through mediated discussion in an open community forum.
We are here to
invite you to this forum. The National Association of Latino Arts and
Culture has agreed to serve as mediators, and we have gathered more
than one hundred fifty new signatures calling for this meeting. All
we need is your participation.
We ask for your
response in writing by May 10. You may send your response via email
to centrowatch@aol.com.
We trust in your
maturity and willingness to engage in the serious task before us. We
hope that your positive response to this invitation will help us all
begin the work necessary to bring a positive resolution to the standing
boycott.
Sincerely,
Erendira Bernal
Save Our Centro Coalition
Sandra Sarmiento
Save Our Centro Coalition
January 8, 2003
|
"Perhaps SOCC's strongest argument against the Centro is its current lack of programming - a reality that becomes even more striking considering the sheer volume of work created there in the past."
Cover Story
San Diego City Beat
January 8, 2003
The following letters to the Editor were sent to San Diego City Beat in response to the Jan. 8, 2003 cover story on the Centro boycott.
|
Letters to the Editor S.D. City Beat
Regime Change
I read your article on the Centro Cultural de la Raza [“Cover Story,” Jan. 8] with great interest. I have great interest because I have been personally involved in the development of Chicano/Latino cultural centers for the last 25 years. I was executive director of the Guadalupe Cultural Arts Center in San Antonio, Texas from 1983 until 1998. During this time, I am not aware of Nancy Rodriguez, who claims to have been an administrator there, to have ever held any such post at the GCAC.
While your detailed article has so many indications of why and how a community-based arts center can go awry of its community, and how its leadership can alienate not only its founders, but the entire community as well, they prove to be too many for me to point out. I can say that it is clear to me that this center needs to have its current leadership removed and to install one that has the backing and blessing of its community, both artistic and general community. A cultural center without arts activities and without a community, is not a cultural center.
Last, an indication of the lack of genuine interest in the community displayed by the current administration, was apparent to me when Nancy Rodriguez called me on occasion to ask my advice regarding her battle with the artists. During this conversation, when I began asking some hard questions regarding her actions and the “Centro,” she became defensive and discontinued the conversation. It was evident to me that she was not interested in hearing anything other than her own views.
Pedro A. Rodriguez,
San Antonio, Texas
Editor’s note: In our Jan. 8 cover story, we incorrectly said Centro Cultural de la Raza Executive Director Nancy Rodriguez was a former administrator at the Guadalupe Cultural Arts Center in San Antonio. This information came from a source deemed reliable, and both Rodriguez and Centro Board President Aida Mancillas failed to respond to two CityBeat requests for a follow-up interview. In response to the above letter, Rodriguez said she was both an arts patron of and juror for the Guadalupe Center. She also participated in several shows there as a performing artist. She said that at no time did she claim to have been employed by the center prior to being hired at the Centro. We regret the error.
Flawed Mission
After reading the article regarding Centro Cultural de la Raza [“Cover Story,” Jan. 8], I wanted to offer two points. As the executive director of a cultural arts center with much the same history as El Centro, and one that contracts artists, and both presents and produces, it is at the core of your basic relationship with artists that the ownership of an artists work is sacred.
While it is true that programs are the property of the organization, the work of the artists, unless specifically commissioned, are not. It is crap, and a lie to offer that every nonprofit owns whatever work is produced at their facility. I would offer as someone who negotiates on behalf of the artist that they are foolish to agree to such an arrangement. The way you own an artist’s work is you buy it. You don’t pay them an hourly rate and give them materials.
I would be shamed to offer artists such an arrangement. Work for hire is exactly that: work for hire. It is a blatant and ethical infringement on an artist’s intellectual property and certainly misrepresents the norm of arts organizations around the country.
The second point is the issue of vision for the organization. This is the second time I have read [executive director] Nancy Rodriguez describe her organization’s future exclusively in terms of size and prestige. In an earlier article she talks about being a multi-million dollar organization.
For me, these are financial goals that clearly relegate programming and services to the community to secondary status. An executive director and board of directors that is mission-driven (as nonprofits should be) would ask, what are the needs and requirements of their communities, and then develop financial goals that would allow them to carry out the work. Apparently, Rodriguez and her board have determined that money and prestige are what their community needs, so that is what they seek. If they are able to raise substantial money, even if it comes at the expense of exploiting its artists, they will consider themselves a success.
“Community control” of it’s own institution was a tenet of the Chicano movement, separating from the community and pandering to the mainstream were not. It is somewhat infuriating to listen to people pay homage to the Chicano movement and it’s legacy, as Rodriguez and Aida Mancillas do, and at the same time carry out activities that are clearly in contradiction.
Anthony J. Garcia, Executive Director, El Centro Su Teatro Denver, Colo.
Culture Crash
I read your account of the misnamed El Centro Cultural de la Raza in San Diego. It is misnamed because of what is there now. To me, it is no longer El Centro Cultural.
The present directors, in my opinion, with their power-hungry desire to have their own center and ethics be damned, should not have stepped on the faces of the original artists, activists and founders. To me, on a scale of 1 to 10, their behavior ranks a minus-15.
They have usurped an artistic enterprise with a 30-year history that brought to San Diego art works, the majority of which were of international caliber, and so recognized.
Whatever the case may be, history should record that the present board of directors, collectively, have killed something far more valuable than anything they have to offer. Having jointly participated in this cultural murder, their subsequent behavior can only be categorized as none other than grotesque.
First, emanating from the present board of directors, there has been an ideological self “liberation” undercurrent.
Second, by edict, the creative works of the artists will henceforth become the private property of the board of directors to do with what they will. This is nothing less than indentured servitude, an insult to the concept of “liberation,” and the first cousin of a fascist state.
Third, they have promised health benefits to the artists they have deposed, if only they would return. This offer is an example of ruthless and sadistic dominance. It is the boot stepping on the face of the deposed with boots that have had their heels and soles coated with honey. It is a classic example of the liberated becoming the oppressors.
Fourth, they have usurped not only the physical plant, but also the name. This is an abhorrent effort to capitalize on something others have created. Furthermore, it is totally dishonest, for it conveys to the public that nothing has changed.
Fifth, in my opinion, the present board of directors should either move out, establish their own center or change the name of the place. Nothing less would establish them as totally dishonest, devoid of any ethics, and antithetical to the deepest spirit of art, artists and the true spirit of Chicano culture.
Octavio I. Romano,
Berkeley (Formerly from Old Town and National City)
To
learn about Save Our Centro Coalition members or events, please email
us at centrowatch@aol.com.
c/s 2005
|